Friday, November 13, 2009

Currently Reading


I've been slowly working my may through some George Orwell essays. I bought the book when I needed some inspiration (and something to steal from) to make a go of it as an essayist. As I'm only on my third essay in the collection, it should seem obvious that the inspiration didn't work. But here I am, writing about it. Of course, I don't have much to say, but I did find the remarkable historical curiosity of the "seaside postcard," a relic from earlier times but still feeling very familiar. The jokes seem to be timeless and, as Orwell notes, seem to stay away from too many topical jokes or captions containing opinions. I'll write more on the essays later, but I wanted to make a note of these postcards--particularly those by Donald McGill--and thought someone might enjoy a little piece of British history.

Monday, November 9, 2009

Currently Reading: Blood Meridian

Which versus That

Chicago Manual of Style on Which versus That

"Which" is for non-restrictive, nonessential clauses (often set off by commas).
"That" is for restrictive, essential clauses.
"Which" can be used for restrictive clauses, as long as the clause is not set off by commas.

Via T__ L__, the AP style guide sez the same.

Via S__ S__, Grammar Girl's Quick and Dirty Tips include basically the same formulation, i.e. which is expendable, that is defining.

That is all.